POP QUIZ: What’s The Difference Between “Junk Silver”, “Constitutional Silver”, And “90% Silver”?

Do you know the difference between “Junk”, “Constitutional”, and “90% Silver Coins”? The difference may surprise you…

Article originally written by Paul Eberhart and guest posted at SD Bullion

Junk Silver Coins, Constitutional Silver Coins, and 90% Silver Coins are all ways to refer to the same thing: pre-1965 / pre-1964 90% silver dimes, quarters, half dollars and dollar coins.

Here we will discuss the current state of the Junk Silver Coin world and how its limited supply continues to dwindle year after year.

The United States used silver coinage for most of its history. These 90% Silver Coins are some of the last remaining silver coin legacies of our forefathers.

Constitutional Silver, 90% Silver and Junk Silver Coins: What’s The Difference?

The difference is in the name you prefer to use.

Some people don’t like the word “junk”, even though it doesn’t mean it’s trash, and some people like to use the word Constitutional, because the US Constitution lays out the requirement for a bi-metallic gold and silver standard.

But no matter which names you prefer, it all identifies the same silver coinage in general.

Article 1 Section 8 of the directs Congress to coin money and fix the weights and measures, and Article 1 Section 10 explicitly says that our money is be be gold and silver coinage.

That said, it wasn’t until the Coinage Act of April 2, 1792 when the congress defined those weights and measures in exact figures.

Most people don’t realize this, but the original definition of one dollar (as in $1.00 USD) is actually a specific weight and purity of silver.

Here it is straight from the 1792 Coinage Act:

Dollars or the same is now current, and to contain three hundred and seventy-one grains and four sixteenth parts of a grain of pure, or four hundred and sixteen grains of standard silver, Half Dollars—each to be of half the value of the dollar or unit, and to contain one hundred and eighty-five grains and ten sixteenth parts of a grain of pure, or two hundred and eights of a grain of standard silver. Quarter Dollars—each to be of one fourth the value of the dollar or unit, and to contain ninety-two grains and thirteen sixteenth parts of a grain of pure, or one hundred and four grains of standard silver. Dismes—each to be of the value of one tenth of a dollar or unit, and to contain thirty seven grains and two sixteenth parts of a grain of pure, or forty one grains and three fifth parts of a grain of standard silver.

The fact that they are “weights and measures” is important. It’s a simple, divisible system of accountability, fraction based. That is to say $1.00 is a specific weight and purity of silver, and a half dollar ($.50) is half of that weight (with the same purity). A quarter dollar ($.25) is one quarter the weight (with the same purity) as one dollar. A dime ($.10) is one tenth the weight (with the same purity) as one dollar.

This is why a silver dollar is the largest, followed by the half dollar, followed by the quarter, and finally ending with the smallest unit of measure – the dime.

Now, since our money was weight and precious metal purity based, this means that a half dollar has the same silver content as two quarters. Likewise, ten dimes have the same silver content as two quarters.

One of the best free websites to track Constitutional Silver Coin melt values is called Coinflation.com, below is a screenshot from their silver coin value page where you can track live silver melt values of older junk silver coins.

The United States has used silver coinage for most of its history.

That is to say, what is normal is for the United States to have silver coinage.

What is not normal is to be using these mostly zinc or cupronickel coins whose melt values are way lower than their legal tender face values.

Have a look how little your pocket change is truly worth in metal value alone.

Why buy Junk Silver?

Constitutional silver coins are some of the most sought after silver there is, and one of the coolest ways to begin investing in silver.

The year 1964, was the last year the US minted circulating 90% silver coins in mass. This means there is a limited fixed supply.

All of the US 90% silver coins that have ever been produced, have been produced. Most of them have likely been melted by now into other silver products, gone forever.

Junk silver coins are sought after for their silver content, and they have collector’s appeal as they are truly a part of history in your hands.

There are many different designs on the coins too. There are a number of variety of eagles, and obverses.

For example, the American Silver Eagle bullion coin of today is basically a rendition of the obverse of the Walking Liberty Half Dollar. There is also the Ben Franklin obverse of the half dollar.

There is the 1964 JFK half dollar (the only year the JFK half dollar was minted in 90% silver). Those are the most common half dollar because they are the least vintage. There are also Seated Liberty half dollars, Barber half dollars, and so on. The older the design, the more expensive – generally speaking.

For the most part, unless you are buying a graded coin or a roll in brilliant uncirculated condition, when a silver investor is buying junk silver, they are buying circulated coins.

In other words, 90% US silver coins that were actually used in day to day transactions way back when. This means that the coins have been used by the general population before finding their way out of circulation.

Therefore, when buying circulated 90% silver coins, some will look very pretty, and some will look very rough, and it will mostly be all in between. Most circulated 90% silver coins have worn over time and use. Their exact silver weight may be slightly diminished with wear on the coin (minute silver flecks have fallen off with wear and tear). That said, every $1 of face value of 90% silver coinage typically contains .715 troy ounces of silver.

Does that mean that if an investor buys a $100 face value bag of 90% silver that it will weigh exactly 71.5 troy ounces of silver?

No, and it has to do with the circulated condition of the coins, so it might contain 71.4 troy ounces again due to this aforementioned wear-n-tear.

That said, most silver investors are not looking for the exact weight, but they are looking for the face value, understanding there is a slight variation in weights due to the wear on any given lot of 90% silver coins.

What if a silver investor gets coins that have been completely worn smooth, with holes drilled in them, with them being clipped, or something else that would seriously diminish the weight?

Those would not be sold as circulated coins.

Those types of severely damaged coins are sold just like that – they are sometimes called “cull”, “severely damaged”, “no dates readable”, “Excessive wear”, and terms like that.

In other words, let’s assume an investor buys a $10 roll of circulated, pre-1965 Washington quarters. It is safe to say that those will neither be in brilliant uncirculated condition, because those would have been pulled out, but that roll of quarters will also not contain clipped, drilled, or cull coins, because those would have been pulled out too.

Average circulated means just that – pocket change that has been used.

One more note about the whole collector’s/historic value of Constitutional silver coins.

Recall the statement that all of the coins that have ever been minted have been minted.

Dwindling Junk Silver Coin Supplies

Much of the silver coinage was melted down in the 1979 and 1980 period when silver spiked in price to near $50 oz. Some experts estimate that 98% of all junk silver coins were in line to be melted down during those spiking silver price periods around the 1980 silver price spike. This means that 90% coins are even more scarce because of having been melted down over the decades since their final production.

And that was not just something that happened in 1980 either. Earlier this year (2018) Silver Doctors broke a junk silver coin story on renewed melting down of 90% silver coins again due to lacking demand.

Although many people think it is illegal to melt 90% silver coinage, it is not. What is illegal is to melt down pennies and nickels, but not the 90% silver coins from 1964 and prior.

You can read about this directly on the US Mint’s website.

So while it is true to say that from a historical perspective, all that has ever been minted is out there already. Much of the 90% silver coins which have been minted have been melted down and cast into .999 silver bars or shot for use in industrial or modern day silver bullion applications.

All the US 90% junk silver coins that have ever been minted is all there will ever be, and because of the melting down of these 90% silver coins from the late 1970s into the future, said 90% silver coins will become even more scarce.

Why else are Silver Investors drawn to Junk Silver Coins?

The short answer: The premiums vs their historic value.

Below is a short video explaining some of the reasons why 90% silver coins are often bought and traded by silver investors still today.

There are two components to the price of any silver coin – the silver content, and the product’s price premium above the live silver spot price.

This is true for all silver coins, including 90% silver coinage.

An investor pays the market rate for the weight of silver they are buying (silver spot price), plus the additional premium that the product carries.

The more sought after, collectible, limited edition, and myriad inputs all factor into what the premium is for any given silver coin or other bullion bar / round out there.

With junk silver, it is a little different.

When silver endures time periods of low demand, as it has lately, the premiums on junk silver are very low.

Conversely when silver demand is very high, the premiums on junk silver go up because those who hold the coins must be enticed to sell them. Remember – it’s not produced anymore, so it has to come out of investors hands to get into the market.

This is best illustrated with this decade long chart on 90% silver coin premiums below.

Notice that 90% silver coin price premiums above silver spot prices spike at times in which silver bullion demand was highest (fall 2008, middle 2013, and late 2015).

For example, when 2015 silver prices were bottoming, the demand for silver bullion products increased dramatically.

In fact, in 2014, the US Mint set a record for the number of American Silver Eagles sold.

Then in 2015, it broke that record. To date, the year 2015 remains one in which the US Mint (see the data on the bottom half of the page) sold the most 1 oz American Silver Eagle Coins.

So we see that in 2014 and 2015, silver demand really took off, and it was for all silver products, which includes generic rounds, and also the junk silver coins. In the chart above, we can see that the premiums on junk silver increased to a percentage premium of over 25% above silver spot prices at the start of 2016.

The fall of 2008 (far left on the chart above) is the biggest glaring premium spike and it was due to many weeks and months where silver bullion dealers had little to no silver products on their shelves and orders where backordered for months at a time.

What do Junk Silver Prices mean for Silver Investors?

There is a double-play here when the premiums are low, as they are right now.

There is both the possibility of physical silver going up in value, and there is also the possibility of the coin premiums going up in value too. This is not merely unique to the Constitutional silver coin market, but it also it has a lot to do with the limited shrinking supply of junk silver coins remaining.

When there is strong demand for investment grade .999 silver bullion, governments mints and private mints can ramp up supply to meet that demand. Much of the silver sourced in doing so comes from the further melting of 90% silver coin supplies.

Yet again, there is no ramping up on the supply of Constitutional 90% silver coins because they are no longer minted. With world and US population growth since 1964, don’t hold your breath waiting for a day in which we use silver coins in day to day commerce again

Thus during high demand durations, higher price premiums and bids must be offered to potential silver coin sellers to entice their 90% silver coins to come to market.

Finally, there is an unspoken rule in the gold and silver coins space, so to say and it has to do with junk silver. The unspoken rule is to watch the junk silver market to gauge ongoing silver bullion market supply demand in general.

When price premiums are low and junk silver is plenty, the demand for silver bullion is not that strong. But when premiums are high, and some of these US 90% silver coins become scarce (like trying to buy Mercury dimes instead of the more typical Roosevelt dimes), those dynamics tell us demand for investment grade silver is very strong.

In other words, if one wants a gauge the status of the physical silver market, one can simply look to the availability and premiums asked for 90% silver coinage.

Bottom Line on Junk Silver Coins

No matter what you call it: Constitutional silver, 90% silver, or junk silver… it all means the same thing.

But whatever you call it, it’s not junk or rubbish in the general meaning of the word.

Constitutional junk 90% silver coins will remain sought after silver, which are both continually dwindling in quantity. As well old US 90% silver coins are a majority, integral part of American history one can still own outright today.

Stack accordingly…

– Half Dollar



About the Author

U.S. Army Iraq War Combat Veteran Paul “Half Dollar” Eberhart has an AS in Information Systems and Security from Western Technical College and a BA in Spanish from The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Paul dived into gold & silver in 2009 as a natural progression from the prepper community. He is self-studied in the field of economics, an active amateur trader, and a Silver Bug at heart.

Paul’s free book Gold & Silver 2.0: Tales from the Crypto can be found in the usual places like Amazon, Apple iBooks & Google Play, or online at PaulEberhart.com. Paul’s Twitter is @Paul_Eberhart.