Dave Kranzler says that historically this type of market behavior has marked the blow-off tops of speculative manias. Here’s why…
People who look for easy money invariable pay for the privilege of proving conclusively that it cannot be found on this earth. – Jesse Livermore
Boeing’s stock has gone parabolic. It’s doubled since April 2017:
The stock now trades at a 31x PE ratio, for whatever that’s worse. I’m sure if I went through the numbers closely, I could find numerous accounting manipulations which added a copious amount of non-cash income to BA’s numbers. BA’s revenues on a trailing 12 month basis are flat. From 2015 to 2016, its revenues declined 1.7%. On a trailing twelve month basis vs. 2016, its revenues have dropped 3.2%.
Historically paying a nose-bleed PE ratio for a company with deteriorating revenues and an enormous amount of debt does not produce a good result. Chasing the price-momentum higher and waiting for a bigger idiot to buy shares from you works well until the music stops. Then everyone gets hurt.
The Dow moved up an average of 120 pts per day in the nine trading days since the end of 2017. This includes one day in which the Dow dared to close 12 pts lower. That one day felt like a bear market. Over this entire period the Dow has appreciated 4.4%. Since the election, including the 1,000 pt plunge in the Dow futures that occurred when it was apparent Trump would win, the Dow has soared nearly 50%.
What’s driving this? Since late August, the public has literally thrown money blindly into passively managed ETFs which automatically distribute the cash inflow by market cap weighting into the stocks in the index that underlies the ETF. This means that most of the gains are concentrated in the stocks in the Dow/SPX with the largest market caps, which then drives the Dow/SPX higher. For instance, last Friday, the Dow was up 0.89% but AMZN was up 2.2%, Netflix was up 1.8%, GOOG was up 1.5% etc.
There’s no telling how much longer this can persist without some type of accident. Judging by the data on cash in customer brokerage accounts at the big online brokers , I would have to believe that this last push from the retail investor is nearing its completion. Data from the fund industry has shown a massive migration of investor cash moving out of actively managed mutual funds and into passive index funds. This would include money managed on behalf of individuals by registered investment advisors.
Most investor sentiment indicators are showing extreme levels of bullishness – historically unprecedented levels. The short interest on the NYSE has melted down nearly to zero. The Acting Man blog has written an excellent post which details the sentiment indicators flashing bright red warning lights – I recommend a perusal: Mother Of All Blow-Offs
For now, the raging bulls chasing momentum conveniently ignore the deterioration in “new orders” and “employment” numbers in deference to the statistically manipulated headline reports that purport to show economic growth. Most of the bullish reports are overweighted with “sentiment” and “hope” metrics that offset declining real economy statistics. Credit card and auto loan delinquencies – both subprime and “prime” – continue to increase a double-digit rates (see WFM or COF’s latest quarterlies, for instance). As for the “prime” credit rating designation of 2017, it’s not your mother’s “prime” credit rating.
At this point I don’t want to speculate on how much longer that Dow/SPX/Naz can go straight up. Historically this is the type of market behavior which has marked the blow-off top of speculative manias and has preceded serious market accidents.
Is this the “Mother Of All Blow-Offs?” Probably.
Part of the commentary above was excerpted from the last issue of the Short Seller’s Journal. Believe it or not, there’s 100’s of stocks that declining or have set-up short-sell opportunities. Long term puts are historically cheap and shorting certain companies is a no-brainer. I had my subscribers short Sears at $12. Last week I presented homebuilder to short that is down 6.7% on the week, so far. To learn about about this newsletter, click here: Short Seller’s Journal information